By -
Justice Rangnath Mishra's report is shocking as well as revealing. A former Chief Justice of Supreme Court, Mr Mishra has recommended 15% reservation for minorities including 10% for the muslims in jobs as well as education. Doesn't Mr. Mishra know that religion based reservation is ultra vires? How can a person of his stature and knowledge recommend so? Even the UPA government seems favourable to the recommendations. Realising that there is a cap on reservation beyond 50%, where from these 15% come? It has also been recommended that this may be drawn from OBC quota. Will the OBCs take it lightly or the country will plunge into the dark days of agitations, dharnas?
Another recommendation of Mr. Mishra is really shocking. He has recommended that the term scheduled caste be made religion-free and be extended to include christians and muslims. It is really shameful that Mr. Mishra even does not know that these are equalitarian religions without any high or low social ranking.
We all know that these so called dalits among muslims and christians are those who converted attracted by the equalitarian philosophy of these religions but conversion has not changed their plight. As religion-based reservation is not possible, the best way would be that votaries of the rights for dalits of other religions should convince these dalits to go back to their parent religion to enjoy the fruits of constitutional safeguards available to scheduled castes.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is Anthropology?

By -
 Despite being a serious student of Anthropology for almost 50 years, the question makes me uneasy. I must admit that I have not been able to pinpoint what Anthropology is not. That could have made my job easy. Here I start with some historical facts. 1.       When Aristotle defined man as a “featherless biped walker” did he know he was defining the limits of Anthropology? 2.       In Class 9 th or 10 th I had read a poem starting with the couplet: “Know then thyself, presume not God to scan; The proper study of mankind is man”. Doesn’t Alexander Pope, the poet, sound an Anthropologist? 3.         Again, the same year, we had a poem by Tennyson on Crimean War, The Charge of the Light Brigade which most of us   must have read; I remember a few lines: “Canons to right of them Cannons to left of them Cannons in front of them ………… Into the mouth of hell Rode the six hundred” N...
Read more

Anthropology Returns..... With a Bang

By -
Image
Dear Readers! For me the Caption of this article is misleading (though, in the beginning you may not agree). The fact is that results of Anthropology in the last decade (except for one year) have been constantly good — more than 10%. However, after IAS 1996 it is for the first time that three in top then have Anthropology as their Optional. [In IAS 1996 three of our students  — Nilesh (7th), Manish (8th) and Piyush (9th) held this record]. Therefore, it is a special occasion for me but I may be disjointed,  as I have to say a lot on different aspects. I “I love anthropology because I’m insatiably curious. Anthropology uniquely spans the arts, humanities, social science and natural sciences, and touches all fields of human endeavor or inquiry. Human origins? Uh huh. Human rights? Certainly. Ontology and the nature of being? Got it. Genome sequencing? Check. Poetics and aesthetics? You bet. Cross-cultural psychology? Please. Climate change? Down cold. Migration and displa...
Read more

Where are the Tribes

By -
Tribes, more often than not, are in the news mainly for the crimes committed against them. Most of us just glance through the news as if they are aliens to us. Unless we are particular about it, most of us even don’t know who amongst us are tribals; or whether tribes exist at all. The exhaustive definition of ‘tribe’ given in ‘merriam-webster.com reads as: Definition of tribe 1a: a social group comprising numerous families, clans, or generations together with slaves, dependents, or adopted strangers b: a political division of the Roman people originally representing one of the three original tribes of ancient Rome c: PHYLE 2: a group of persons having a common character, occupation, or interest 3: a category of taxonomic classification ranking below a subfamily also: a natural group irrespective of taxonomic rank The synonyms of ‘tribe’ are: blood clan, family, folks, house, kin, kindred, kin(s)folk, line, lineage, people, race, stock. In that sense any social group with a particular c...
Read more